Tuesday, December 15, 2009

Taking about women....

Talk about arriving at the party late. I’m going to talk about Elizabeth Lambert. Yes, I realize that everything that can possibly be said about the University of New Mexico defender has already been said. The frat boys have chimed in with their lesbian fantasies and the hardcore feminists have reminded us how misogynistic and double standard the coverage of the incident has been. It’s pretty clear that the young woman was guilty of doing little more than what Kevin Harmse earned a pro career with and that the insane over-reaction by much of the mainstream media had everything to do with what body parts she does or does not have.

So, I’m not going to add to that noise. Rather, I wish to use her story as a jumping off point to criticise my own coverage of women’s football.

Here we are in the 20th post of my all day marathon and it’s the first reference to the women’s game. In spite of the fact that nearly half the registered players in Canada are female, and that the women’s national team is much higher ranked than the men’s, this blog puts 90 per cent of its focus on the men’s game. And I’m a source that tends to be at least aware of the program.

I sometimes wonder if I’m the worst kind of hypocrite when it comes to the women’s game. The good liberal in me feels that I should try to provide some coverage, but the coverage I provide is far more surface than it is with men’s soccer. I can’t fake a base of knowledge that isn’t there and I will fully admit that what knowledge I have comes from me researching, rather than seeking out info for the sake of it. I will support the women’s program, but I’m not always sure I’m a fan of it.

So does that make my attempts to cover it condescending? I don’t know. I do know that when the Lambert story broke that most soccer blogs dragged out their seldom used “girlz game” label for the day and had a good laugh at the crazy blond chick trying to behead her opponent. I resisted, because I thought I’d be clichéd, and decided to let the whole thing pass.

What I didn’t do was try and tell a good story about the women’s game. I didn’t seek out info on the Canadian team and I didn’t write an opinion piece on their preparation heading into a World Cup qualifying campaign. Instead I sat back and smugly played the morally superior card by not touching the Lambert story.

I’m not sure I was all that superior.

I’m also not sure if there is an audience here for women’s news. Certainly, what stories I do run tend to get very few if any comments. I have no way of tracking individual posts for amount of reads, but I have my suspicions.

I don’t pretend to have any answers with this post, but I wanted to throw it out there. Just how interested are you in seeing women’s coverage here?


This is the twentieth post in my 24-hours of blogging marathon. The purpose is to raise some funds to allow The 24th Minute to continue to provide quality (and quantity) coverage of Canadian, MLS and world football.

If you like what I do, please consider supporting the Toonie project -- my call for a voluntary $2 a month subscription to the blog ($24/year).

Donations of any amount are accepted through PayPal (link to the right) or e-mail money transfer (dgrollins@gmail.com). Also e-mail me to arrange other forms of donation (or trade).

9 comments:

MrTuktoyaktuk said...

Having an active professional league provides more to talk about. WPS for the most part fufilled their targets in terms of turnout, visability and IMHO did far better than MLS in embracing social media.

Anonymous said...

Why don't you invite Elaine, the woman who ran Go Big Red to be a guest contributor to 24th Minute. She is a a very knowledgeable person when it comes to the Canadian women's soccer scene and could lend a very interesting perspective from time to time.

Jason Davis said...

Not at all, but that might just be me. I've long since gotten over any guilt resulting from my disinterest in women's soccer. I understand the appeal, and I appreciate the ability of the women who play; I just can't seem to find any part of me that is in the slightest bit intrigued by it.

I suppose it's just rationalizing, but I don't feel any pressure to care about women playing any other sport, and so I don't let the noise around me about women's soccer bother me too much.

At the same time, I would completely resent any implication that my "ignoring" of the women's game is misogynistic.

Duane Rollins said...

I'd be more than happy to have Elaine contribute if she were interested. If you know her, have her drop me a line at dgrollins@gmail.com

Dan said...

Don't know her at all, but a 1 minute search turned up this: elaine@gobigred.ca

not sure if the e-mail still works

I would be interested in info on the women's game

Anonymous said...

It is a noble pursuit, Duane, to be sure. However if their was a demand for such coverage there would be sites popping up all over the place.

All you would end up doing is spending alot more time writing and watching about a game that, frankly, not many visitors to your site will care about.

Hell, even my sisters don't follow or enjoy watching women's sports.

prizby said...

Elizabeth Lampert is well over played...That poor girl got hit hard, a lot worse than professional players do. Look at what Chris Morgan did to Iain Hume...he only got a yellow card...this poor girl got it so bad compared to Chris Morgan

Anonymous said...

i'll post anonymously this time so i can be honest - i encourage you to talk more about the women's team if you feel like it, but i won't bother reading it unless there's a major international tournament going on. (and i don't skip your other posts, including the manchester city ones, which tend to be written really well.) There's nothing wrong with women's soccer, it's just not something i care about (and Toronto would need a televised WPS team for any chance of that changing - they have to sell me on the product, not assume that i 'should' watch women's soccer.)

oh, and my girlfriend is a hardcore fan of the NBA and she's never, ever willingly sat down to watch a WNBA game. and this is a league that the NBA has tried their best to 'force' on television watchers, where you don't need to make an effort to find a televised game. expecting a lot of interest in the canadian women's soccer team, who i have no idea what they're doing right now or where i could watch it? pipedream.

Anonymous said...

I would love to see some WPS coverage. Its an exciting league. I wish there was a team somewhere in Canada. Im male in my 30s.
I feel the way about women's hockey. Unfortunatly there isnt a pro league with televised games.

Post a Comment